Bethlehem sits just six miles south of Jerusalem in the West Bank. The Church of the Nativity, built over the traditional site of Jesus' birth, is one of the oldest continuously operating churches in the world — dating to 339 AD. The silver star marking the birthplace is in a small grotto beneath the altar; expect a queue, but the moment is profound.

Don't rush through Bethlehem. The Shepherd's Fields east of town offer a peaceful counterpoint to the busy church — you can sit in a cave where shepherds once sheltered and sing "O Little Town of Bethlehem" where it actually happened. The Milk Grotto, a soft white cave where tradition says Mary nursed Jesus, is a hidden gem most groups skip.

Manger Square is the heart of town, lined with shops selling olive wood carvings made by local Christian artisans. Buying here directly supports the shrinking Christian community in Bethlehem — a meaningful way to connect your visit to the present-day reality of the land.